Friday, June 22, 2012

Identifying Aristarchean Commentary in the Venetus A Scholia


A guest post by Thomas Arralde, Class of 2013, College of the Holy Cross

The overarching philosophy behind our work in the Homer Multitext is to be as exact and as comprehensive as possible. Last summer we digitally inventoried every scholion in the entirety of Book 1 of the Venetus A manuscript, and created a diplomatic edition of all the scholia dating to the 10th century. We also make our findings accessible and searchable to facilitate our own research as well as that of others. All people and places referenced in the scholia were tagged with a unique identifier that corresponded to person and place inventories.

In our work on editing the scholia of Book 1 of the Venetus A, we noticed that the word “ὅτι” (because) often began a scholion, and that these scholia often continued “Ζηνόδοτος γράφει” (Zenodotus writes). Our consistent documentation of when Zenodotus, the first publisher an Alexandrian edition of Homer, appeared in the scholia allowed us to observe how frequently his name appeared in the context of these ὅτι scholia. Our comprehensive work on the scholia gave us results that were authoritative for the whole of Book 1, notable for being the book of the Iliad with the greatest number of scholia in the Venetus A, as well as Books 3, 4, and 5. From the statistics we compiled, we were able to form hypotheses about the significance of these scholia, and why they appear so formulaically, which leads us now to the great Homeric scholar Aristarchus.

Aristarchus of Samothrace took over the directorship of the Library of Alexandria in the middle of the 2nd century BC, after the death of his predecessor Aristophanes of Byzantium. The work of Aristarchus is seen as an important turning point in the history of the Homeric tradition, in which the works of Homer become relatively rigid and texts were studied outside the context of performance (Nagy 1996: 110). Because of his pivotal role in the textual history of the Homeric epics, identifying the comments of Aristarchus from what does survive is an important task for Homeric scholars. But doing so is not always a straightforward task, since the scholiast does not always write the name of the scholar whose work he is referring to (Nagy 1997: 117).

One way of identifying scholia attributable to Aristarchus in the Venetus A, we discovered, could be the use of the word ὅτι at the beginning of scholia. As our team was editing the scholia of Book 1, every time a name appeared we placed it in TEI markup, and provided a unique identifier for each name. In our markup, Zenodotus was given the identifier “pers15,” so that his every appearance looked as follows: 

[persName n=“pers15”]Ζηνόδοτος[/persName] (with pointy brackets for the square—the blogging software keeps reading the pointy brackets as actual code, so we had to replace them here). Because of this markup, only a simple search was required to find every reference to Zenodotus in our transcriptions. With this information it was an easy task to see in what scholia Zenodotus appeared, and how many of them were ὅτι scholia. We applied the same search to Aristarchus, who appeared in our marked-up scholia as
[persName n=“pers16”]Ἀρίσταρχος[/persName], which led to an exciting discovery. Aristarchus’ name almost never appears in these scholia, but Zenodotus’ does quite frequently. This and other observations lead to the possibility that these scholia are more or less direct quotations from Aristarchus’ lost works.

Critical signs next to lines of the Iliad on 15V of the Ven. A
Our current understanding of critical signs is that Aristarchus used them both in the scroll of the Iliad text he worked from and in the scroll of his comments to the text so that the two could be easily matched (Bird 2009). With the advent of the codex, the use of critical signs next to both became superfluous and were mostly removed from the scholia but mostly retained next to the text of the Iliad. Evidence of Aristarchus’ usage is the presence of the word “ὅτι” at the beginning of scholia, on its own meaning something like “the sign is here because”. The structure of the scholia in Aristarchus’ notes is supposed to have been sign, lemma, and then the scholion itself.
A rare scholion (from 28R of the Venetus A) that follows the sign-lemma-ὅτι comment sequence that we think Aristarchus’ commentary had

Although the signs that we believe to have been written in Aristarchus’ commentary scroll do not appear in most cases in front of the Venetus A scholia, the word that started the explanation of that sign, ὅτι, often survives as the beginning of the comment. One would expect, then, that when a ὅτι appears there was a critical sign in the scholion that is no longer there, but is retained next to the text. In Book 1 of the Venetus A, however, this does not happen as often as such a rule supposes. In this Book ὅτι begins a scholion which does not have a corresponding critical sign in the main text ~43% of the time. If the critical sign has disappeared in both locations, ought the ὅτι really be translated as “the sign is here because” when no sign exists?
Iliad 1.216, on 16R in the Venetus A, has no Critical sign placed next to it.
Yet the scholion on this line begins with ὅτι
 The absence of critical signs does not continue throughout the Venetus A, however. In Book 3 more than 95% of the scholia that begin with ὅτι are accompanied by a critical sign. What is it about the scholia in Book 1 that causes the scribe to include critical signs with ὅτι scholia 50% less of the time than in Book 3? Is it the great density of scholia that continues through the first book but subsides somewhat in later books that causes the disparity? All of these questions require further investigation, and as we continue to edit more scholia we expect to find further evidence to assist us in our inquiries.

Furthermore, Aristarchus is rarely cited in scholia which begin with ὅτι; his name appears in such scholia only twice in Book 1. This is astounding considering in Book 1 there are 136 ὅτι scholia and 61 occurrences of Aristarchus’ name and little overlap between the two. More frequently citations of Aristarchus appear “thus Aristarchus” or simply “Aristarchus” followed by the comment. What we find instead is that Zenodotus’ name more often follows after ὅτι (30% of the time in Book 1, 28% in Book 3). When Zenodotus appears in the scholia of Book 1, ~85% of the time it is in a ὅτι scholion. If the ὅτι follows Aristarchus’ method of writing his commentary, why is Zenodotus so often cited in these scholia? It could be that the scribe of the Venetus A is quoting directly from Aristarchus (or someone else quoting directly from Aristarchus) in the ὅτι scholia since Aristarchus would not refer to himself in the 3rd person, and would be commenting on the edition of his predecessor, Zenodotus. In fact, there is scarcely ever a mention of any scholar later in date than Aristarchus found in these scholia.

We know that the system of Critical signs used in the Venetus A comes from Aristarchus’ edition of the Iliad. The fact that the ὅτι scholia virtually never name Aristarchus or scholars later than him, and name Zenodotus with an unusual frequency, leads us to believe that they are authentic Aristarchean commentary. Work is ongoing and findings in Book 2 have already yielded tantalizing results. As further evidence comes to light we hope to come closer to answering the critical question of where the information in our scholia comes from.

Bird G. 2009. “Critical Signs - Drawing Attention to ‘Special’ Lines of Homer’s Iliad in the Manuscript Venetus A,” 89–155 in Recapturing a Homeric Legacy, ed. C. Dué, Washington DC.
Nagy G. 1996. Poetry as Performance. Cambridge.
Nagy G. 1997. “Homeric Scholia,” 101–122 in A New Companion to Homer, ed. Morris and Powell. Leiden & New York.

148 comments:

  1. We will deal with the beguiling Escorts young lady who will continue running with you even night or day time and she will fulfill your starting and end energized necessities. We are the top most Mumbai Escorts association and we select the most energized call young women and Escorts in Mumbai. We have ceaselessly entertained our customers with astonishing organizations Mumbai Escorts.

    ReplyDelete
  2. By painting them you can use Swami Rajender ji Black magic specialist in kanpur, from another time in order to be changed (call now @ 8725088250).

    Visit Now :-

    Black Magic Specialist In Kanpur
    Vashikaran Specialist In Kanpur

    Black Magic Specialist Kanpur

    Vashikaran Specialist Kanpur

    ReplyDelete
  3. The information is very useful and interesting. Thanks for sharing and do not forget to visit our website





    Packers and movers in Govandi
    Packers and movers in Kalyan

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think your blog will easily to get the correct market, because its having the piece of content. so it can easily to attract the visitors.





    Packers and Movers in Ganeshkhind
    Packers and Movers in Thergaon
    Packers and Movers in Tathawade

    ReplyDelete
  5. Tatkal Railway Ticket Agent gives you the best cheap rate of railway ticket booking Chandigarh, railway ticket booking Chandigarh, Confirmed Tatkal Ticket Booking Chandigarh Call @ 9999606515.

    Tatkal Rail ticket agent

    train ticket agents in delhi

    confirm train book Chandigarh

    Railway Ticket Booking Agent

    ReplyDelete
  6. JaiBalaji Packers and Movers in Mumbai, team of professionals. The expert team will survey of your material/consignment and the strength of men, kind of vehicles, and material of packages or insurance required, accordingly. https://jaibalajipackers.com/packers-and-movers-mumbai/

    ReplyDelete

  7. Kamal Packers provide excellent transportation services for hassle-free shifting from one place to another location. So by hiring our professional services you can smoothly move from one place to another location without any botheration and worry.
    https://kamalcargopackersmovers.in/packers-and-movers-thane/

    ReplyDelete

  8. The Best Five is the no.1 packers and movers in Chandigarh in serving the top quality logistic services including packing, moving, unpacking, relocation, household, offices ,shifting, loading, unloading, transportation etc from the past decade in India.
    https://thebest5.in/packers-and-movers-chandigarh/

    ReplyDelete
  9. Love marriage specialist astrologer Pandit Hari Ram Ji provides a reputable person call @ 7837876237 with the best and authentic services in the love marriage astrology in India.

    Love Problem Solution ####
    Vashikaran Specialist ####
    Love Marriage Specialist ####
    Vashikaran For Love ####
    Vashikaran For Love ####
    Black Magic For Love ####
    Vashikaran For Love ####

    ReplyDelete
  10. Astrologer in Canada, Astrologer in Brampton, Astrologer in Hamilton, Astrologer in Winnipeg, Astrologer in Surrey, Astrologer in Toronto, Astrologer in Vancouver, Astrologer in Ottawa, Astrologer in Calgary

    Visit Now :-

    Astrologer in toronto

    Astrologer in vancouver

    Astrologer in ottawa

    Astrologer in calgary

    Astrologer in edmonton

    Astrologer in Montreal

    Love problem solution canada

    ReplyDelete
  11. Astrologer in Canada, Astrologer in Brampton, Astrologer in Hamilton, Astrologer in Winnipeg, Astrologer in Surrey, Astrologer in Toronto, Astrologer in Vancouver, Astrologer in Ottawa, Astrologer in Calgary

    Visit Now :-

    Astrologers in Canada

    http://www.astrologerincanada.ca/about-us.html

    http://www.astrologerincanada.ca/contact-us.html

    Astrologer in Brampton

    Astrologer in hamilton

    Astrologer in winnipeg

    Astrologer in Surrey

    ReplyDelete
  12. There will be problems as well. Vashikaran Specialist In Mumbai But it might so Aghori ji happen that problems can be Call Now @ 9517888489.

    Visit Now :-

    Vashikaran specialist in delhi ####
    Vashikaran specialist in mumbai ####
    Vashikaran specialist in pune ####
    Vashikaran specialist in bangalore ####
    Vashikaran specialist in hyderabad ####
    Vashikaran specialist in chennai ####

    ReplyDelete
  13. There will be problems as well. Vashikaran Specialist In Mumbai But it might so Aghori ji happen that problems can be Call Now @ 9517888489.

    Visit Now :-

    Vashikaran specialist in surat ####
    Vashikaran specialist in Vadodara ####
    Vashikaran specialist in kolkata ####
    Vashikaran specialist in chandigarh ####
    Vashikaran specialist in jaipur ####

    ReplyDelete
  14. This ancient practice has not still lost its value and significance Aghori ji has so many uses in people’s life.(Call Now 9517888489).

    Visit Now :-

    Black magic specialist in Delhi ####
    Black magic specialist in pune ####
    Black magic specialist in mumbai ####
    Black magic specialist in Bangalore ####
    Black magic specialist in hyderaBad ####
    Black magic specialist in chennai ####
    Black magic specialist in surat ####

    ReplyDelete
  15. Thank you very much for keep this information Share this.
    Jai Balaji Packers and Movers
    Jai Balaji Packers and Movers
    Jai Balaji Packers and Movers
    Jai Balaji Packers and Movers
    Jai Balaji Packers and Movers
    Jai Balaji Packers and Movers Agra
    Packers and Movers Agra-Jai Balaji @9838276084 movers and packers agra
    (packers and movers services provider all india)
    Jai Balaji Packers and Movers Company in agra 15+ years of experience in movers and packers services. 24*7 Call 09838276084 safe and reliable service with high quality packing material at affordable price.
    Email- info@jaibalajipackersagra.com
    Contact - +91 9838276084, 9808623702
    jaibalajipackersandmoversagra@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  16. Prestige packers and movers best in field of packers and movers in Thane. With our more than a decade long experience we understand your needs at best. We prioritize our customer need and provide best services. https://www.prestigepackersandmover.co.in/

    ReplyDelete
  17. Hello everyone, if you want to get proper sexual satisfaction by our exoert and young girls. contact us on :-9873940964. you will be guaranteed satisfied. for get more details visit my website :-
    Lajpat Nagar Escorts
    Mahipalpur Escorts

    ReplyDelete
  18. I am happy to find this post very useful for me, as it contains lot of information. I always prefer to read the quality content and this thing I found in you post. 
    Click Here to Get More Sites readmore
    packers and movers allhabad
    packers and movers varanasi
    Sangam packers and movers allahabad Business Page
    Movers and packers allahabad
    Movers And Packers allahabad
    packers and movers
    Packers And Movers In allahabad
    Movers and Packers Varanasi
    Packers and Movers Varanasi. We are a nationwide packing company that specializes in loading packers and movers, domestic moving, warehouse,

    ReplyDelete
  19. Mahipalpur Call Girls | 9999965857 | Book Escorts in Mahipalpur at Hotels

    mahipalpur escorts $$$$$$
    saket escorts $$$$$$
    nagar escorts $$$$$$
    karol bagh escorts $$$$$$
    dwarka escorts $$$$$$

    ReplyDelete
  20. Escorts Service in Connaught Place 9711199171 Incall Connaught Place Escorts


    connaught place escorts $$$$
    greater kailash escorts $$$$
    saket escorts $$$$
    dwarka escorts $$$$
    rohini escorts $$$$

    ReplyDelete
  21. Packers and Movers Varanasi - Sangam packers and movers allahabad
    Packers and Movers Varanasi. We are a nationwide packing company that specializes in loading packers and movers, domestic moving, warehouse, car carrier,
    packers and movers varanasi
    packers and movers in varanasi
    We want our customers to be stress free while going home. Our knowledge and expertise The hardest moving assignment seems so simple. With years of experience, we are very capable to deliver whatever promises we make. And we believe that nothing is impossible.
    http://www.sangammovers.com/

    ReplyDelete
  22. Shreedurga Boys PG in gurgaon provides a comfort stay, and you can get complete rest. Always choose a pg in Gurgaon which have all necessary facilities and provide good quality food. There are so many pg accommodations in Gurgaon which provide best services to the people at affordable rates as well. https://shreedurgapg.com/

    ReplyDelete
  23. vasant kunj Escorts for Gathering, Private & Get-togethers. Our Premium, Excellent and High-Class vasant kunj escorts will satisfy your dreams. An organization that offers Outcall benefits in all vasant kunj zones. Additionally, we offer modest vasant kunj escorts administrations. Book now

    rohini escorts ##
    laxmi nagar escorts ##
    nehru place escorts ##
    lajpat nagar call girls ##
    karol bagh escorts ##
    greater kailash escorts ##
    ghaziabad escorts ##
    kaushambi escorts ##

    ReplyDelete
  24. Delhi Escorts Service available for bookings 9711199171 , Fulfill your sexual dream with Independent Call Girls Delhi, You can Hire Models vila Call Girls in Delhi for hotels and beaches. Fulfill your wish and find Independent Call Girls in Delhi.


    nehru place escorts $$$
    mahipalpur escorts $$$
    vasant kunj escorts $$$
    south ex escorts $$$
    chanakyapuri escorts $$$

    ReplyDelete

  25. Ankitech brand hospital furniture have rich looks, inventive plans and utility, aside from normal hospital furniture straight forwardly identified with patients and human services suppliers. We do manufacture and supply all type of best hospital furniture like hospital beds, medical furniture, ICU Bed, Fowler bed, semi Fowler bed. https://ankitech.in/hospital-furniture/

    ReplyDelete
  26. Ghaziabad Call Girls are the finest choice for High Class Services@ 9873940964

    ghaziabad escorts $$$
    noida escorts $$$
    greater noida escorts $$$
    kaushambi escorts $$$
    vasundhara escorts $$$

    ReplyDelete
  27. Aerocity escorts|9999965857 | Independent escorts service in Aerocity

    aerocity escorts ?????
    preet vihar escorts ?????
    indirapuram escorts ?????
    paharganj escorts ?????
    vaishali escorts ?????

    ReplyDelete
  28. I'm riyapandey call girs in Faridabad.Faridabad escort agency give you out call and in call service.If you want book call girl visit here:-


    greater kailash escorts ##
    lajpat nagar escorts ##
    laxmi nagar escorts ##
    mahipalpur escorts ##
    malviya nagar escorts ##
    nehru place escorts ##

    ReplyDelete
  29. This is the official page for Packers and Movers chandigarh. With the expertise in the packing and moving services, our branch at chandigarh has been professionally delivering satisfying outcomes the people across India.Call Us - 9001694151.

    packer and movers in chandigarh $$$$
    packer and movers chandigarh $$$$
    movers and packers chandigarh $$$$
    movers and packers in chandigarh $$$$
    packers and movers kharar $$$$
    packers and movers solan $$$$

    ReplyDelete
  30. get exclusive night call girls in delhi. we provide only hot and sexy call girls in your location. all type of call girls are available. contact 9873777170 http://www.exclusivenightgirls.com/gallery-russian-escort-service-delhi.html
    Delhi Escorts

    saket escorts service

    karol bagh escorts service

    dwarka escorts service

    nehru place escorts service

    mahipalpur escorts service

    vasant kunj escorts service

    south ex escorts service

    chanakyapuri escorts service

    ReplyDelete
  31. Thank you for helping people get the information they need. Love back by vashikaran

    ReplyDelete
  32. The blog was absolutely fantastic! Lot of great information which can be helpful in some or the other way. Keep updating the blog, looking forward for more contents...Great job, keep it up..
    Indian Astrologer in Toronto | Best Indian Astrologer in Toronto | Top Indian Astrologer in Toronto

    ReplyDelete
  33. Welcome to VIP Delhi Escorts, the escort agency with the excellent skills of love making. Our Call Girls service in Delhi can make anyone happy because we are available 24/7. You can feel free to call us: 9873940964 anytime.

    lajpat nagar escorts ###
    munirka escorts ###
    east of kailash escorts ###
    hauzkhas escorts ###
    pitampura escorts ###
    mayur vihar escorts ###
    paharganj escorts ###
    vasundhra escorts ###
    kaushambi escorts ###
    vaishali escorts ###

    ReplyDelete
  34. We always remain prepared to supply greater than expected benefits to our customers. The best colors of life are Delhi and thus you have to observe the evenings here this ardent season. Help to create a secure payment only once you meet our escort. 100% confidentiality assurance can be found from our conclusion.
    Delhi escorts
    Pune escorts
    Mumbai escorts
    Jaipur escorts
    Goa escorts service
    Nainital escorts
    Dehradun escorts
    Haldwani escorts
    Haldwani escorts
    Gurgaon escorts

    ReplyDelete

  35. شركة تسليك مجاري بالرياض
    شركة الصفا كلين تقدم لكم خدمة تسليك المجاري بافضل ادوات التسليك فشركتنا تحتل المرتبة الاولى بين جميع شركات المملكة فهى افضل شركة تسليك مجاري بالرياض على الاطلاق حيث يوجد لدينا افضل فريق عمل بالرياض وليس بالرياض فقط بل بجميع انحاء المملكة العربية السعودية .

    شركه عزل خزانات بالرياض
    تعد شركتنا افضل شركه عزل خزانات بالرياض لاننا منذ زمن طويل نعمل بهذة المهنة ولدينا الخبرة الكافية لاداء اي عمل مهما كانت صعوبتة او مهما كان مدى خطورتة فنحن نثق بشكتنا وبفريق عملنا لاننا من افضل شركات عزل الخزانات بالرياض.

    شركه عزل مسابح بالرياض
    شركة عزل مسابح بالرياض من افضل شركات عزل المسابح بجميع انحاء المملكة فشركتنا لديها افضل ادوات العوازل فشركتنا تعد افضل شركه عزل مسابح بالرياض

    شركه مكافحه النمل الابيض بالرياض
    النمل الابيض من اخطر الحشرات التى يمكنها تدمير المنزل بأكملة وايضا تدمير الاثاث ويشكل ايضا خطورة على صحة الاطفال لذالك شركه مكافحه النمل الابيض بالرياض تقدم اليكم افضل الحلول للتخلص من النمل الابيض بشكل نهائي فشركتنا تستعمل افضل انواع المبيدات الحشرية التى تقضي تماما على النمل الابيض وكثير من الحشرات الاخري.

    شركه تنظيف خزانات بالرياض
    افضل شركة تنظيف خزانات بالرياض شركة الصفا كلين لتنظيف الخزانات بالرياض بل بالمملكة العربية السعودية بأكملها.

    ReplyDelete
  36. Independent noida Escorts | i am an independent call girl | you can visit me for fun. get full satisfaction. Call: 09873940964 | visit = http://anushkadas.in/contact.html noida Call Girls
    East Of Kailash Escorts

    Govindpuri Escorts

    Green Park Escorts

    Gtb Nagar Escorts

    Janakpuri Escorts

    Jj Colony Escorts

    Ajmeri Gate Escorts

    Anand Vihar Escorts

    Ashram Escorts

    ReplyDelete
  37. Independent Call Girls in Delhi | Service available 24*7 hours | Call Us +91-9899900591 | Independent Housewives are availableat your nearest location | visit us at = http://www.sexydelhicityescorts.com/
    Delhi Call Girls💋
    *-*
    Delhi Escort Service💋
    *-*
    Female Escorts in Delhi💋
    *-*
    Call Girls in Saket 💋
    *-*
    Laxmi Nagar Call Girls💋
    *-*

    ReplyDelete
  38. Female Escort Services in Connaught Place. i am an independent call girl so i provide my fun service independently. i am available for both incall or out call services. Visit https://anushkaaggarwal2.blogspot.com/ or Call 9999965857
    punjabi bagh Escort Service ***

    rohini Escort Service ***

    mahipalpur Escort Service ***

    nehru place Escort Service ***

    east of kailash Escort Service ***

    kalkaji Escort Service ***

    new friends colony Escort Service ***

    south extension Escort Service ***

    safdarjung Escort Service ***

    ReplyDelete
  39. Feel the Attitude Improvement between Independent Escorts in Mumbai

    mumbai escorts !!!!!!
    russian call girls mumbai !!!!!!
    independent mumbai call girls !!!!!!
    thane escorts !!!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  40. Thanks for sharing your information...It's very useful for many users...I will be waiting for your next postAstrologers in Edmonton | Best Astrologer in Edmonton | Astrologer in Edmonton

    ReplyDelete

  41. Shakti Packers and Movers Chandigarh are best packers and movers in Chandigarh. Shuffling from one place to another is easy and manageable with the help of expert packers and movers in Chandigarh , and it is beneficial to save significant cost on making arrangements solely. Hiring a certified and reputed shifting contractor will return real value for your investment. https://www.packerandmoverinchandigarh.com/

    ReplyDelete
  42. nice blog... thanks to share info about your services. This is really useful.
    Vashikaran Specialist
    Vashikaran Specialist Astrologer

    ReplyDelete
  43. nice blog... thanks to share info about your services. This is really useful.
    Vashikaran Specialist
    Vashikaran Specialist Astrologer

    ReplyDelete
  44. Great post, I appreciate you and I would like to read your next post. Thanks for sharing this useful informationAstrology in Edmonton | Astrologer in Edmonton | Best Astrologer Service in Edmonton

    ReplyDelete
  45. Thanks For Create Such Kind Of Informative Website. It Is Really Useful According Your Current Topic. Please Keep This Continue To Help The People Who Are Looking For This Topic. After See Your Niche I Have Recommended Your Website With My Friends Also.
    My name is Neha Gupta. I run my independent Mumbai Escorts Service
    . I am an independent Mumbai escort girl. My service charge is low according the market price. My service is super, because I know very well the personal need of my each customer. I am comfortable to provide my Mumbai Escorts Service at your home or in Hotel. 24X7 I am available. Visit- http://www.nehagupta.biz/ Call- +91 9OO4458359

    Mumbai Escorts
    Mumbai Call Girls
    Escort Service In Mumbai
    Mumbai Escort Girls
    Bandra Escorts
    Juhu Escorts
    Andheri Escorts


    ReplyDelete
  46. Ask Free Question- About Love Vashikaran, Love Back, Inter Caste Love Marriage, Black Magic. We Are Vashikaran Specialist Astrologer. We Have 20 Years’ Experience As A Vashikaran Specialist. We Have 10,000+ Satisfied Clients. Contact Us To Discuss About Your Problem. Get Positive Result In One Hour. Visit Our Website Http://Www.Lovevashikaranexpert.In/ Call Us +91 9915707766

    Love Vashikaran Specialist Baba Ji
    Vashikaran Specialist In Delhi.
    Inter Caste Love Marriage Specialist.
    Love Back Astrologer.
    Black Magic Specialist.
    Love Problem Solution Baba Ji.
    Powerful Vashikaran Upay.

    ReplyDelete
  47. I Saw Your Website Carefully. Thanks For Create Such Kind Of Informative Website. Your All Content Is Relevant To Your Subject. I Say Keep It Continue, Because Your Website And Subject Is Meaningful For The Users. I Have Recommended Your Website With My Friends Also. I Am Ritu Sharma. I Am An Independent Mumbai Escort Girl. I Deal In Mumbai Escorts service. I Am Very Hot And Sexy. Being A Mumbai Escort Girl I Have Five Years’ Experience. That’s Why I Understand The Each Personal Needs Of My Every Client. My Service Charge Is Low And Service Is Super. You Can Avail My VIP Mumbai Escorts Service At Your Home Or In Hotel. I Am Comfortable To Provide Mumbai Escorts Service In Local And Outside Also. Visit www.escortservicemumbai.net Call +91- 9OO4OO9481
    Visit The Links Below And Have A Look At My Various Mumbai Escort Services-
    Mumbai Escorts
    Mumbai Call Girls
    Mumbai Escorts In Vile
    Parle

    Bandra Escorts
    Juhu Escorts
    Andheri Escorts

    Mumbai Escorts In Colaba


    ReplyDelete
  48. Thanks For Create Such Kind Of Informative Website. All Content Is Relevant To Your Subject. Keep It Continue, Because Your Website And Subject Is Meaningful For The Users. After See Your Niche I Have Recommended Your Website With My Friends Also.
    My Name Is Priya Singh. I Run My Own Mumbai Escorts Service. I Am An Independent Mumbai Escort Girl. I Am Beautiful And Hot. My Service Charge Is Low And Service Is Super. Being Professional I Have Seven Years’ Experience As An Escort Girl. So I Understand And Feel The Real Needs And Requirement Of My Each Client. You Can Taste Me Any Time. According The Convenience You Can Avail My VIP Escort Service At Your Home Or In Hotel Also. To Book My VIP Mumbai Escort Service Call +91 9987215552. Visit http://www.escortagencyinmumbai.com/
    Visit The Links Below And Have A Look At My Various Mumbai Escort Services-
    Mumbai Escorts
    Mumbai Call Girls
    Mumbai Escorts In Vile Parle
    Bandra Escorts
    Juhu Escorts
    Andheri Escorts
    Mumbai Escorts In Colaba

    ReplyDelete
  49. Ask Free Question- About Love Vashikaran, Love Back, Inter Caste Love Marriage, Black Magic. We Are Vashikaran Specialist Astrologer. We Have 20 Years’ Experience As A Vashikaran Specialist. We Have 10,000+ Satisfied Clients. Contact Us To Discuss About Your Problem. Get Positive Result In One Hour. Visit Our Website Http://Www.Lovevashikaranexpert.In/ Call Us +91 9915707766
    Have A Look At Our Astrological Services Through The Given Links Below-


    Love Vashikaran Specialist Baba Ji
    Vashikaran Specialist In Delhi.
    Inter Caste Love Marriage Specialist.
    Love Back Astrologer.
    Black Magic Specialist.
    Powerful Vashikaran Upay.
    Love Problem Solution
    Baba Ji.


    ReplyDelete
  50. This is truly a great read for me. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work!.Visit For:
    Indian Astrologer in Toronto | Astrologer in Toronto | Top Indian Astrologer in Toronto

    ReplyDelete
  51. Thanks for sharing your wonderful information...It's really nice blog...Keep updating more information from your blog...It's very helpful for many astrology users... Astrologer in New York | Famous Indian Astrologer in New York | Top Astrologers in New York

    ReplyDelete
  52. Pretty good post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts
    Top Indian Astrologer in Toronto | Astrologer in Canada | Pandith Astrologer in Ontario

    ReplyDelete
  53. Really Your Website Is Very Useful And Informative According Your Subject. Please Keep Continue Your Effort To Help The People Who Are Looking For Such Kind Of Topic.
    Ask Free Question- About Love Vashikaran, Love Back, Inter Caste Love Marriage, Black Magic. We Are Vashikaran Specialist Astrologer. We Have 20 Years’ Experience As A Vashikaran Specialist. We Have 10,000+ Satisfied Clients. Contact Us To Discuss About Your Problem. Get Positive Result In One Hour. Visit Our Website http://www.vashikaranhelps.com/ Call Us +91 9915537976
    Have A Look At Our Astrological Services Through The Given Links Below-

    Vashikaran Specialist
    Vashikaran Specialist In Delhi
    Inter Caste Love Marriage Specialist Baba Ji
    Back Magic Specialist Baba Ji
    Love Problem Solution Baba Ji

    ReplyDelete
  54. Delhi escorts for 100% satisfaction at cheap rate. Call Us +91- 9999965857 High profile Anjalikaur college models avail here with Delhi call girls & escort service in Delhi.

    call girls defence colony ####
    call girls east of kailash ####
    call girls hauzkhas ####
    call girls pitampura ####
    call girls mayur vihar ####

    ReplyDelete
  55. Are you Seeking for Khan Market Escorts or Fantastic College Call Girls in Khan Market, Call Us @ +91-9873940964 Wow then our Independent Escorts service in Khan Market will make your day.

    Call Girls Khan Market ####
    Call Girls Safdarjung Enclave ####
    Call Girls Green Park ####
    Call Girls Chattarpur ####
    Call Girls Chanakyapuri ####

    ReplyDelete
  56. Good post ! Astrology and life are connected to each other. Astrology is the best way to solve future problems.
    Best astrologer in Sydney
    Black Magic Removal in Sydney
    Get ex love back in Sydney

    ReplyDelete
  57. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  58. Welcome Gentlemen, my name is Nehabatra and here as an Indian Escort in Lajpat Nagar. who gives requesting warm and awesome relationship for respectable men. Contact us on :-9899900591. visit my website:-
    Uttam Nagar Escorts

    Tilak Nagar Escorts

    Laxmi Nagar Escorts

    Malviya Nagar Escorts

    Hauz Khas Escorts

    Defence Colony Escorts

    Chanakyapuri Escorts

    Paschim Vihar Escorts

    Punjabi Bagh Escorts

    Rohini Escorts

    ReplyDelete

  59. Really Your Website Is Very Useful And Informative According Your Subject. Please Keep Continue Your Effort To Help The People Who Are Looking For Such Kind Of Topic.
    Ask Free Question- About Love Vashikaran, Love Back, Inter Caste Love Marriage, Black Magic. We Are Vashikaran Specialist Astrologer. We Have 20 Years’ Experience As A Vashikaran Specialist. We Have 10,000+ Satisfied Clients. Contact Us To Discuss About Your Problem. Get Positive Result In One Hour. Visit Our Website http://www.vashikaranhelps.com/ Call Us +91 9915537976

    Have A Look At Our Astrological Services Through The Given Links Below-

    Vashikaran Specialist
    Vashikaran Specialist In Delhi
    Inter Caste Love Marriage Specialist Baba Ji
    Back Magic Specialist Baba Ji
    Love Problem Solution Baba Ji

    ReplyDelete
  60. Choosing Delhi escorts can be the answer to all your concerns. These escorts in Delhi have been working since very long efforts and they know that every customer needs sensual needs.

    vasundhra escorts!@!!!@!!!
    ghaziabad escorts!@!!!@!!!
    gurgaon escorts!@!!!@!!!
    noida escorts!@!!!@!!!
    greater noida escorts!@!!!@!!!

    ReplyDelete
  61. Independent Delhi escorts are expanding and special hot Delhi offers escorts and college girls who cover girls for beauty.

    raj nagar escorts /////!!//////
    vaishali escorts /////!!//////
    vasundhra escorts /////!!//////
    ghaziabad escorts /////!!//////
    gurgaon escorts /////!!//////
    noida escorts /////!!//////
    greater noida escorts /////!!//////

    ReplyDelete
  62. If you are searching for escorts in Delhi, 9711199012 You can hire youngest girls for the sexual night with call girls in Delhi city of Delhi.

    Delhi Escorts !!!!!!@!!!!!!
    Aerocity Escorts !!!!!!@!!!!!!
    Connaught place Escorts !!!!!!@!!!!!!
    Dwarka Escorts !!!!!!@!!!!!!
    Karol bagh Escorts !!!!!!@!!!!!!
    Lajpat nagar Escorts !!!!!!@!!!!!!
    Laxmi nagar Escorts !!!!!!@!!!!!!
    Mahipalpur Escorts !!!!!!@!!!!!!
    Nehru place Escorts !!!!!!@!!!!!!
    Saket Escorts !!!!!!@!!!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  63. VIP Female Escorts Saket Enjoy Vip Model Girls Direct to your room at http://www.delhiescortsservices.co.in/ We provides Truly Hot service to our clients. independent Saket Call Girls available 24*7
    Russian Call Girls in Nehru Place

    Female Escorts in Saket

    Call Girls in Karol Bagh

    Dwarka Escorts

    Call Girls Mahipalpur

    Vasant Kunj Call Girls

    Escorts in South Ex

    Chanakyapuri Call Girls

    Call Girl Service in Connaught Place

    ReplyDelete

  64. A medium-term fun with the beautiful Udaipur Call Girls is extremely a remarkable ordeal that you should encounter regularly. Along these lines, it would be helpful for you to feel uncommon and add chipper recollections to your affection life. contact us on :- 09711199012 and visit my website :- call girls -malviya nagar.

    call girls surajkund

    call girls hauz khas

    call girls defence colony

    call girls chanakya puri

    call girls mayur vihar

    call girls paschim vihar

    call girls punjabi bagh

    call girls greater kailash

    ReplyDelete
  65. Beautiful High Profile Marathahalli Escorts. As a High Class Marathahalli Escorts Service we offer satisfied service to the clients that make easy for them to get are you seeking for Call Girls Marathahalli or Fantastic College Call Girls in Marathahalli, Escort Service. working Available 24/7.

    sanjay nagar escorts /////!!//////
    independent call girls bangalore /////!!//////
    Escorts In bangalore /////!!//////
    electronic city escorts /////!!//////
    independent hsr layout escorts /////!!//////
    marathahalli escorts /////!!//////

    ReplyDelete
  66. Astrologer Aghori ji - We provides Black magic specialist. You should always meet a best vashikaran specialist in aghori baba ji. gives full assurance for result. Consult with Black Magic Specialist Babaji can change your life.( Call Us - 9022563470 ).

    Black magic specialist in Bangalore /////!!//////
    Black magic specialist in surat /////!!//////
    Black magic specialist in vadodara /////!!//////
    Black magic specialist in jaipur /////!!//////
    Vashikaran specialist in bangalore /////!!//////
    Vashikaran specialist in chennai ####

    ReplyDelete
  67. Astrologer Ajay Shastri - Astrologer In Canada - We provides Black magic specialist. You should always meet a best vashikaran specialist in baba ji. gives full assurance for result. Consult with Black Magic Specialist Babaji can change your life.( Call Us - +1 5875074472 ).

    Astrologer in Canada //////!!/////
    Astrologer Canada //////!!/////
    Astrologer in Surrey //////!!/////
    Astrologer in Ottawa //////!!/////
    Astrologer in Vancouver //////!!/////
    Astrologer in Toronto //////!!/////

    ReplyDelete
  68. Hellow everyone ,If you are looking for Call girls in Noida. if you want book call girls in Noida. call us on :- 9873940964. for get fully sexual satisfaction by our girls.visit my website:-
    mayur vihar escorts

    paschim vihar escorts

    punjabi bagh escorts

    rohini escorts

    pitampur escorts

    chattarpur escorts

    vasant vihar escorts

    daryaganj escorts

    ReplyDelete
  69. Faridabad Escorts and College Call Girl in Faridabad is available 24 hours (call now 09873940964) for erotic escort services in Faridabad call girls.

    Greater kailash escorts!!!!!@!!!!!!!@!!!!!!!
    Hauz khas escorts!!!!!@!!!!!!!@!!!!!!!
    Janakpuri escorts!!!!!@!!!!!!!@!!!!!!!
    Kapashera escorts!!!!!@!!!!!!!@!!!!!!!
    Karolbagh escorts!!!!!@!!!!!!!@!!!!!!!
    Lajpat nagar escorts!!!!!@!!!!!!!@!!!!!!!
    Mahipalpur escorts!!!!!@!!!!!!!@!!!!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  70. I Am Thankful To You For Create Such Kind Of Informative Website. Really It Is Useful According Your Current Topic. I Suggest To Keep This Continue For Those People, Who Are Looking For Such Kind Of Niche. After See Your Niche I Have Recommended Your Website With My Friends Also.
    I am Arpita Jain. I run my own Mumbai Escort Service. We provide Mumbai Call Girls in low cost according the current market price. Our service is super, because we know very well the personal requirement of our each customer. We are comfortable to provide our Mumbai Call Girls Service at your home or in Hotel. Visit- http://www.arpitajain.org/mumbai-call-girls/ Call- +91 9OO4458359
    Visit The Links Below And Have A Look At My Various Escort Services-
    Mumbai Escorts
    Mumbai Call Girls
    Escort Service In Mumbai
    Mumbai Escort Girls
    Bandra Escorts
    Juhu Escorts
    Andheri Escorts

    ReplyDelete
  71. Thank you for such a well written article. It’s full of insightful information and entertaining descriptions Astrologer in New York | Best Indian Astrologer in New York | Top Astrologers in New York

    ReplyDelete